How to Write a Memoir (When the Hardest Character Is You)

Mary Karr was a poet first. She spent years writing poetry at Syracuse, publishing collections that earned her a real reputation in a field where reputations are hard to come by and even harder to keep. Poetry was the form she knew. It was the thing she'd trained for.

But there were these scenes from her childhood in East Texas that wouldn't leave her alone. Her mother's episodes, her father's silence, the heat of that house. She'd been carrying them for decades, and poetry couldn't hold them. The scenes needed room to breathe, room to accumulate, room to sit in one moment long enough for the reader to feel the weight of it.

The Liar's Club came out when Karr was forty. She'd been a writer for twenty years before she found the right container for the stories that mattered most. Which tells you something about memoir. The material finds you long before you find the form.

If you're sitting on scenes from your own life, ones you keep circling back to in conversation or in your head, that's worth paying attention to. Here's what I've learned from studying the writers who figured out how to put those scenes on the page.

You're a character, and you have to build yourself on the page

The "I" in a memoir is a construction. This is the part that trips up most first-time memoir writers, because it feels dishonest. You're writing about your own life. Shouldn't you just be yourself?

You can't. The person living the experience and the person narrating it are separated by time and by everything you've understood since. Mary Karr's narrator in The Liar's Club is a child, watching her parents with the kind of terrifying clarity children sometimes have when they sense something is wrong but can't name it. The adult Karr shaped that voice. She chose what the child noticed and what the child missed. The gap between what that character understands and what the reader understands is where the book gets its power.

Vivian Gornick calls this the distinction between situation and story. The situation is what happened. The story is what you've made of it, the meaning you've drawn out over years of turning it over in your mind. If you just report the situation, you end up with a timeline. If you find the story inside the situation, you end up with a memoir.

The scenes you can't stop thinking about are the ones that matter

Don't start with chronology. I know that's the instinct. Born here, grew up there, went to this school, married this person. Chronology is comfortable because it gives you a built-in structure, but it also flattens everything. Your tenth birthday gets the same weight as the night your father left.

Start with the scenes that haunt you. The ones you've told at dinner parties, the ones that come back when you're trying to fall asleep, the ones you can still feel in your body when you think about them.

Frank McCourt didn't begin Angela's Ashes with a timeline of his family's emigration from Ireland to Brooklyn and back. He started with hunger and rain and the smell of a pub and his father singing songs with drink on his breath. The sensory details came first because those were the things McCourt couldn't forget, the things lodged so deep in memory that decades of distance couldn't dull them. The structure emerged from the accumulation of those scenes, building a picture of poverty that felt lived rather than reported.

If you're stuck on where to begin, make a list of ten scenes you can't stop thinking about. Don't worry about order. Write them as fragments. The connections between them will start to show themselves, and those connections are your book's spine.

Grief has a structure, and you can write inside it

Joan Didion wrote The Year of Magical Thinking in eighty-eight days. Her husband had died of a heart attack at the dinner table. Their daughter was in a coma. Didion sat down and wrote the book in one sustained act of attention, and what came out reads like grief itself: circling, repetitive, returning again and again to the same moments because that's what a grieving mind does. It goes back. It replays. It tries to find the seam where things might have gone differently.

The book circles the night Dunne died the way your mind circles a loss you haven't absorbed. Didion will be discussing something else entirely, hospital logistics or a conversation with a doctor, and then she's back at the dinner table. The repetition is the structure. She didn't impose a form on the grief. She let the grief dictate the form.

I think about this when writers tell me they don't know how to organize their memoir. Sometimes the answer is that the emotional experience you're writing about already has a shape, and your job is to notice it. Grief circles. Addiction spirals. Coming of age moves in lurches, long stretches of sameness broken by moments that change everything. The structure is already there if you're willing to follow the feeling instead of forcing a three-act plot onto something that doesn't move in three acts.

The trail teaches you what the memoir is about

Cheryl Strayed thought Wild was about a hike. She'd walked the Pacific Crest Trail alone at twenty-six, over a thousand miles from the Mojave Desert to the Bridge of the Gods in Oregon. She had blisters and a too-heavy pack and no real experience. That was the book, she figured. A woman walks a very long way.

But as she wrote, the book kept pulling toward her mother. Bobbi, who'd died of cancer at forty-five. Bobbi, whose death had unraveled Strayed's family and sent her into years of heroin use and reckless decisions. Strayed didn't plan that. She didn't outline a book about motherlessness. The writing revealed it, scene by scene, draft by draft, until she couldn't ignore that the trail was just the container and the grief was the content.

I'm not entirely sure what to do with that insight except to say: trust the writing to show you what you're actually writing about. You might think your memoir is about your career or your marriage or the year you spent abroad. But there's probably something underneath that, some question you've been carrying without naming it, and the act of writing scene after scene will eventually surface it. You won't see it in the outline. You'll see it in the draft, on page 80 or page 150, the moment when you realize you've been writing about your father the whole time, or about fear, or about a version of yourself you left behind somewhere.

That's the strange thing about memoir. You think you're the expert because it's your life. But the writing knows things you don't, or at least things you haven't admitted yet, and the only way to access them is to keep putting scenes on the page and paying attention to which ones keep pulling you back.

That's what we send writers every morning. One reflection to sit with before you open the draft.

Stop staring at the blank page. Start writing with purpose.

A free daily reflection delivered to writers every morning. Quotes from literary masters, an original reflection, and a prompt to get you writing.

Join 1,000+ writers. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.