Things I've Noticed About Gothic Fiction

Some things I keep thinking about when it comes to gothic fiction, after spending too much time in houses that don't want me there:

The house is never just a house. In almost every gothic fiction trope worth talking about, the building is a character. It has moods. It has memory. Ann Radcliffe understood this in 1794 when she wrote The Mysteries of Udolpho, and every gothic novelist since has basically been renting rooms in the structure she built.

Gothic fiction readers don't want to be scared the way horror readers do. They want to be unsettled. There's a difference. Scared is a jolt. Unsettled is a feeling that follows you out of the book and sits in the corner of the room while you're trying to fall asleep.

The "explained supernatural" is one of the most underrated gothic fiction tropes. Radcliffe invented it. Every ghost in her novels turns out to have a rational explanation. But here's the thing: by the time you get to the explanation, you've already spent two hundred pages afraid. The explanation doesn't undo the dread. It just gives your rational mind something to hold onto while your body is still in the dark hallway.

Toni Morrison's Beloved might be the most important gothic novel written in the last fifty years. 124 Bluestone Road is haunted, literally and otherwise, and Morrison proved something the genre had been circling for centuries: that gothic fiction is one of the best ways we have to write about historical trauma. The house remembers what the characters try to forget.

Pregnant women keep showing up in gothic fiction and I'm not entirely sure the genre has reckoned with why.

Laura Purcell's The Silent Companions does something I think about a lot. The threat isn't a ghost or a monster. It's painted wooden figures that might be moving when nobody's looking. That's a gothic fiction trope taken to its logical extreme: the inanimate object that refuses to stay inanimate, the domestic space that won't behave the way domestic spaces should.

Most gothic fiction tropes are really about confinement. A woman trapped in a castle, a family trapped in a house, a mind trapped in a body that won't stop remembering. The walls don't have to be literal. They just have to feel like they're closing in.

There's a version of gothic fiction that's essentially a weather report. Fog, rain, mist, cold. And it works. The atmosphere does half the storytelling before a single character speaks a word.

Morrison once said, "All water has a perfect memory and is forever trying to get back to where it was." She was talking about her writing process, about returning to places and feelings, but she could've been describing gothic fiction itself. The genre is obsessed with return. With what comes back. With the thing you buried that didn't stay buried.

The villain in gothic fiction is almost never a stranger. He's the husband, the father, the uncle, the guardian. The call has always been coming from inside the house.

I think the reason gothic fiction tropes have survived for over two hundred years is that they're not really about ghosts or castles or storms. They're about the feeling of knowing something is wrong and not being able to prove it. That feeling hasn't gone anywhere.

Stacey Halls set The Familiars during the real Pendle witch trials of 1612, and the scariest parts aren't the accusations of witchcraft. They're the scenes where a pregnant woman realizes the people around her have been making decisions about her body and her future without telling her. The historical record did most of the gothic work for Halls. She just had to let it breathe.

There's a contrarian reading of gothic fiction that says the genre isn't dark at all. That it's actually optimistic. The heroine survives. She escapes the house, or the marriage, or the madness. She names what was done to her. In a literature full of trapped women, the fact that the trapped woman almost always gets out is worth noticing.

Modern gothic fiction has mostly moved from castles to ordinary houses, and I think it got scarier when it did. A castle is already strange. A semi-detached in Lancashire with something wrong in the walls, that's where you live. That's where you sleep with the lights off.

Secrets are the engine. Every single gothic fiction trope traces back to someone who knows something they won't say, or something the house knows that the characters don't, or some buried history pushing its way up through the floorboards like roots through concrete and the whole plot is really just the slow ugly process of that secret becoming visible.

I'm not sure whether gothic fiction creates anxiety in readers or just gives a name to anxiety they were already carrying. Both feel true.

The best gothic fiction tropes work because they take something safe and make it uncertain. A home. A family. A locked door. The genre doesn't introduce danger from outside. It reveals that the danger was already there, built into the foundation, waiting to be noticed.

That's what a daily writing practice does, too. You sit down, you look at the thing you've been avoiding, and you put words around it. Some mornings the page feels like a well-lit room. Other mornings it feels like a hallway you can't see the end of. You write anyway.

See all gothic fiction writing resources.

Stop staring at the blank page. Start writing with purpose.

A free daily reflection delivered to writers every morning. Quotes from literary masters, an original reflection, and a prompt to get you writing.

Join 1,000+ writers. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.