Fanfiction

How to Write Fanfiction That Sharpens Your Craft

Kia Orion | | 5 min read

Before Rainbow Rowell published a single novel, she spent years writing advertising copy during the day and fanfiction at night. Most people skip this part of her biography. They jump straight to Eleanor & Park and the bestseller lists. But the fanfiction years weren't the warmup. They were the training.

When Rowell wrote Fangirl in 2013, she built the entire novel around a college student named Cath who writes Simon Snow fanfiction. Cath isn't dabbling. She's prolific, she has a massive readership, and her fic is better than most of the original fiction being workshopped in her university classes. Rowell wrote Cath that way on purpose. She knew what that world felt like from the inside, knew how seriously fic writers take pacing and voice and continuity, because she'd done the same work herself for years before anyone was paying her for it.

Here's the part that gets interesting. Rowell became so invested in Simon Snow, the fictional character inside her fictional character's fanfiction, that she eventually wrote Carry On, an entire original novel set in that world. Then Wayward Son. Then Any Way the Wind Blows. She turned her character's fanfiction into a real, published trilogy. The skills she'd built writing fic, the instinct for serialization pacing, the ability to keep a reader emotionally committed across hundreds of thousands of words, the ear for how characters sound when they're alone versus when they're performing, all of it transferred directly into her career. She didn't leave fanfiction behind. She brought it with her and built on top of it.

Borrowed characters teach you what your own characters need

There's something specific that happens when you sit down to write a character someone else created. You can't just make them do whatever you want. If you're writing Harry Potter or Katara or Wednesday Addams, the reader already knows how that person talks, what they'd notice walking into a room, how they'd react to being embarrassed. You have to match it. And matching it requires a kind of reverse engineering that most writing workshops never teach.

You end up asking questions you wouldn't think to ask about your own characters. Why does this person use short sentences when they're angry? Why do they deflect with humor instead of going quiet? When you get it right and a reader comments "this sounds exactly like them," you've just proven you understand characterization at a mechanical level. You know what makes a voice consistent.

That skill doesn't disappear when you start building from scratch. You just redirect it. Instead of matching someone else's character, you're maintaining the internal logic of your own. The muscle is the same.

Serialization builds the muscle that outlining can't

Beth Reekles was fifteen years old when she started posting The Kissing Booth on Wattpad. She wrote it chapter by chapter, publishing each one as she finished it, with millions of readers following along in real time. There was no going back. No restructuring act two after she'd figured out the ending. Each chapter went live and stayed live, and the next one had to pick up where it left off.

That book got a traditional publishing deal. Then a Netflix movie. Then two sequels.

The conventional writing advice would say Reekles did everything wrong. She didn't outline. She didn't revise before showing anyone. She wrote in public, with all the mess visible. But what she built in the process was something you can't get from outlining alone: the ability to trust her instincts mid-draft. She learned to write forward, to commit to a scene and let it stand, to end a chapter in a way that made people come back tomorrow.

I'm not sure why serialization trains those instincts as well as it does, but I think it has something to do with the fact that you can't hide. When your chapter is live and readers are responding, you learn very quickly what a dead scene feels like. You learn what momentum is because you can feel it break.

This is the kind of thing we think about every morning. One reflection, one question, before you open the draft.

Free. Every morning. Unsubscribe anytime.

Fandom literacy is genre expertise by another name

Xiran Jay Zhao grew up inside fandom. Anime, mecha, Chinese historical dramas. When they published Iron Widow, reviewers reached for words like "genre-bending" and "fresh," but anyone who'd spent time in fandom spaces recognized exactly what Zhao was doing. The found-family dynamics, the enemies-to-lovers tension that doesn't resolve cleanly, the way power relationships stay complicated even after the characters decide they care about each other. These are structures that fandom has been workshopping for decades.

What Zhao understood, and what a lot of traditionally-trained writers miss, is that deep immersion in fandom discourse gives you a sophisticated map of reader expectations. You know which tropes carry emotional weight. You know when subverting an expectation will feel thrilling versus when it'll feel like a betrayal. You've absorbed thousands of variations on the same story shapes, so you can feel, almost instinctively, where a narrative wants to go and where it can be redirected without losing the reader.

That kind of genre knowledge usually takes writers years of deliberate study to develop. Fandom compresses the timeline because you're not just reading. You're reading, and arguing about what you read, and writing your own version, and reading other people's versions, all at the same time. It's the most intensive genre education available, and nobody gives you a certificate for it.

The transition to original fiction is smaller than people think

The biggest difference between writing fanfiction and writing original fiction is that you have to build the house yourself. In fic, the architecture already exists. The world, the relationships, the history. You're arranging furniture inside a structure someone else designed. When you go original, you're pouring the foundation too. That's real, and it's hard, and it takes practice.

But the furniture-arranging skills are the same. How to pace a scene. How to earn an emotional beat instead of just announcing it. How to write two characters in a room and make the reader feel the specific quality of tension between them. Fanfiction teaches all of that. The writers who struggle most with the transition aren't the ones who lack skill. They're the ones who don't realize how much skill they already have.


I think about this whenever writers tell me they feel guilty about their fic years, like they were procrastinating on "real" writing. Rowell's career is built on the foundation she laid writing fic. Reekles learned to trust her narrative instincts at fifteen. Zhao turned fandom fluency into a debut that landed on bestseller lists. The practice was real the whole time.

That's the question worth sitting with before you start today's draft. What did you learn during the writing that nobody was grading?

The best fanfiction writers treat every chapter like it matters. That attention to craft starts before you open the draft.

Free. Every morning. Unsubscribe anytime.

K

Kia Orion

Author of The Writer's Daily Practice, the #1 Bestselling book in Journal Writing and Writing Skills. He writes a free daily reflection for writers.

Keep reading

Stop staring at the blank page. Start writing with purpose.

A free daily reflection delivered to writers every morning. Quotes from literary masters, an original reflection, and a prompt to get you writing.

Join 1,000+ writers. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.